What: All Issues : Aid to Less Advantaged People, at Home & Abroad : America's Poor : H.R. 1308. Child Tax Credit and Military Tax Breaks/Vote to Instruct House Conferees to Extend the Child Tax Credit to Low Income Families As Quickly As Possible and Prevent the Inclusion of Additional Tax Breaks for Wealthy Individuals During Conference Committee Negotiations with the Senate. (2003 house Roll Call 398)
 Who: All Members : New York, District 2 : King, Pete
[POW!]
 
H.R. 1308. Child Tax Credit and Military Tax Breaks/Vote to Instruct House Conferees to Extend the Child Tax Credit to Low Income Families As Quickly As Possible and Prevent the Inclusion of Additional Tax Breaks for Wealthy Individuals During Conference Committee Negotiations with the Senate.
house Roll Call 398     Jul 21, 2003
Member's Vote
(progressive
or not)
Progressive Position
Progressive Result
(win or loss)

The $350 billion tax cut package enacted earlier in the congressional session included a provision to increase the child tax credit-which was, in essence, a tax cut for families with children-from $600 to $1000. The final version of the tax legislation, however, did not extend the child tax credit increase to low-income families; only middle and high income households benefited from the increase in the child tax credit. In response, House and Senate Democrats rallied around the child tax credit issue, attempted to grind the legislative process to a halt, and otherwise tried to make life miserable for Republican leaders. After several weeks of debate, Republicans leaders proposed legislation to extend the child tax credit to low-income households. Also included in the child tax credit extension were additional tax breaks for military families and high-income individuals. The legislation passed both the House and Senate in different forms and a conference committee was convened to iron out differences between the two child tax credit bills. On this vote, Representative Van Hollen (D-MD) motioned to instruct House conferees to insist on the Senate's language during conference committee negotiations. In contrast to the House bill, the Senate's version extended the child tax credit increase to low-income families immediately upon enactment. Van Hollen's motion to instruct had two additional provisions which were intended to: 1) prevent House conferees from including additional tax breaks for high-income earners in the conference; and 2) require completion of the conference report in a timely manner. Progressives supported the motion to instruct because, in their view, allowing low-income families to benefit from the child tax credit increase as quickly as possible was an important step toward providing financial assistance to the poorest individuals in society. Progressives also opposed the additional tax breaks for wealthy individuals which were included in the House bill and favored Van Hollen's effort to prevent the inclusion of those tax breaks in the conference report (a conference report is the final version of legislation). An overwhelming majority of Democrats voted in favor of Van Hollen's motion to instruct but the motion failed on a party-line vote of 193-212, thereby failing to obligate House conferees to adopt the Senate's language on the child tax credit legislation during conference committee negotiations.

N Y L
Issue Areas:
Key: Y=Yea, N=Nay, W=Win, L=Loss